Why we show clients two routes, never three

Three options feel generous. In practice they slow decisions down and water every idea. Here is how two sharp routes get better work approved faster.

Written by

Samuel Akaro

Role

New business lead

Published

Reading time

6 min read

Written by

Samuel Akaro

Role

New business lead

Published

Reading time

6 min read

Designer at a desk in a dim studio, working through client design routes
Designer at a desk in a dim studio, working through client design routes


The problem with three

When we started the studio we always showed three routes. One safe, one bold, one in between. Clients almost always picked the middle one, and the middle one was never our best work.

Three options turn a creative review into a negotiation. People mix and match, and the final idea ends up with pieces of everything and the strength of nothing.

Why the middle wins

There is a reason the middle option gets picked. It feels safe for everyone in the room. Nobody has to defend it to their boss, and nobody has to admit the bold route scared them a little. The trouble is that safe for the room is rarely right for the brand.

We saw it happen on a rebrand for a food company in 2017. The bold route had a hand-drawn wordmark and a colour nobody else in the category used. The safe route was clean and forgettable. The client chose the middle route, which borrowed the colour from one and the type from the other. Two years later they came back and asked us to do the bold route properly.

Three options also cost more. Every route needs research, design, mockups and a rationale. Spread that effort across three and each one gets a third less thinking. Clients pay for the extra route and receive weaker work in return.

What changed

Now we show two routes. Each one is complete, argued for and tested with real customers before the meeting. The conversation moves from which bits do you like to which future do you want.

Two routes also make the trade-off honest. With two options there is no middle to hide in. Each route is a real bet with real consequences, and the conversation turns to strategy, which is where it should have been all along.

Two is not a compromise

Some clients worry that two feels like less choice. In practice they get more. They see two fully developed futures instead of three sketches, and they can judge each one on how it would actually live in the world.

How we build two routes

Each route starts from the same brief but answers it in a different way. One might lean on heritage, the other on where the market is heading. Both have to be good enough to ship on their own.

We test them before anyone outside the studio sees them. That means showing them to five to eight real customers, mocking them up on the client’s own channels and checking they still work at small sizes.

  • A one-line idea that explains the route in plain words

  • Real applications, not a logo on a white page

  • What we heard from customers, good and bad

  • What it would cost and how long it would take to roll out

What goes into a route

A route is more than a logo. By the time we present it, each route has a name, a short written idea and a set of real applications. We show the website homepage, a social post, the packaging or product screen, and one piece of signage or merchandise. If the client sells in shops, we show the shelf.

We write a one-page rationale for each route. It covers the insight behind it, who it is for and what it asks the business to commit to. Some routes need a new tone of voice. Others need new photography or a different product name. We list all of that so nobody is surprised later.

We also show the weak spots. Every route has them. Maybe the bold colour is hard to print on recycled board, or the custom typeface needs an extra licence for the app. Naming the risks up front builds trust and saves months of back and forth.

Running the meeting

We present the two routes back to back with the same structure, so nobody is swayed by a nicer slide. Then we stop talking. The first five minutes of reactions usually tell us more than the next hour.

We ask the room to pick a direction, not a set of parts. If a client loves the type from one route and the colour from the other, we read that as a sign neither route is finished. We go back and sharpen the one they are closer to.

After the meeting

We never ask for a decision in the room. We send the full presentation the same afternoon with a short summary of what we heard. The client team then gets two working days to talk it through without us.

Then we meet again for thirty minutes. By this point most teams have a clear favourite, and the conversation is about refining it. If they are split, we run a quick test with customers and let that settle it.

  • Day one: present both routes and listen

  • Same afternoon: send the deck and our notes

  • Two days later: a short call to agree a direction

  • If needed: a one-week customer test to break a tie

When we break the rule

Some briefs are genuinely open. A new company with no history might need a wider look first. In those cases we run a short exploration with mood boards and rough sketches, and only then commit to two routes.

What clients tell us

The most common feedback is relief. Senior teams are busy, and three half-finished options make them do the creative director’s job. Two finished routes let them do theirs, which is deciding where the business goes next.

Founders tend to like it most. They often have a clear instinct and want a partner who will sharpen it, not hand them a menu. One founder told us it was the first design review that felt like a strategy session.

Marketing teams like the paper trail. Because every route comes with a written rationale, they can explain the decision to the rest of the company without us in the room.

The result

Approvals take half as long, and the work that ships is closer to what we believed in on day one.

We track this on every identity project. Since moving to two routes in 2019, the average time from first presentation to approval has dropped from six weeks to three. Revision rounds fell from four to two. And the route we recommend now gets chosen about 80% of the time, up from roughly 40%.

Try it on your next review

You do not need a studio to use this. Next time you present work, cut your options to two, make each one complete and write down why you believe in it. Then show both with the same structure and ask for a direction, not a list of favourite parts.

It feels risky the first time. By the third review, going back to three will feel strange.

User 1

Samuel Akaro

New business lead

Limited slots this quarter

Have a project in mind?

We reply within one working day. No mailing lists.

Limited slots this quarter

Have a project in mind?

We reply within one working day. No mailing lists.

Limited slots this quarter

Have a project in mind?

We reply within one working day. No mailing lists.

Vantor

One email a month: new work, one useful idea and what we’re reading. 6,400 designers and founders subscribe.

Visit

Rua da Boavista 84, Lisbon

118 Greene St, New York

© Vantor Studio Lda. All rights reserved.

Vantor

One email a month: new work, one useful idea and what we’re reading. 6,400 designers and founders subscribe.

Visit

Rua da Boavista 84, Lisbon

118 Greene St, New York

© Vantor Studio Lda. All rights reserved.

Vantor

One email a month: new work, one useful idea and what we’re reading. 6,400 designers and founders subscribe.

Visit

Rua da Boavista 84, Lisbon

118 Greene St, New York

© Vantor Studio Lda. All rights reserved.

Create a free website with Framer, the website builder loved by startups, designers and agencies.